Best Scene,Worst Scene.

[The Restless Shadow]

In RotK there was many Great things,
but then their was also things that people didn't like.
So basicly....
What scene's did you like the most.
and what scene's could you really live without?
I'll go first.....
(Remember these are your Top picks,)
(not just scenes you like)

Scenes I Love!
1.Minas Morgul
2.Pelanor Fields
3.Pippin singing/Faramir Riding
4.Frodo and Galadriel

Scenes I Could live without.
1.Gollum eating the fish
2.When Frodo wakes up and laughes
(That just bugs me)
And that's it(Not much I hated)
And now...it's your turn!

[Legolas]

I loved ALL the scenes and i couldn't live if one was missing. If I don't see the EE, i'm going to Die!!! ( not really but you know...) I hear that there actually going to put what happened to Sarumon... sounds awesome

1. Aragorn gets crowned. ( the WHOLE thing, and when he sees Arwen too, all of that.)
2. When The Eagles pick up Frodo and Sam
3.The Entire battle at Minas Tirith ( yes, the WHOLE thing.)
4. When Galadriel help frodo up when he fell down.
5.When Merry and Pippin are smoking and Aragorn, Gandalf, Legolas, and Gimli come up to them at Isengaurd.

And I could go on and on and on and on and on etc etc.

I lovd the whole movie!

[Arandur]

I loved the whole thing aswell. I'll pick the ones I loved the most and that come into my mind at the moment.

1) Pippin singing/Denethor pigging out/Faramir's suicide ride.
2) The Battle of Pelennor Fields.
3) Sam crying about Frodo rejecting him and telling him to leave. (Sean is such a wonderful actor )
4) The reuion of Arwen and Aragorn. That was so heart-warming.

I could also go on and on and on, like the Energizer Bunny (Like Earendil [someone that most of you don't know] would say)... but I'll shush my wee self.

[Galadriel]

Best scene:
~ Denethor's pyro act. Especially when Pippin tries to intervene.
~ the beacon scene. It just blew me away.
~ when we first see Minas Tirith.
~ Gandalf galloping through Minas Tirith.
~ Gandalf whacking Denethor with his staff. I couldn't stop laughing.

Worst scene:
~ Shelob. I'm an arachnophobic, I could never like it, although I will admit it was well filmed.
~ Gollum and the fish.
~ Galadriel speaking in Frodo's mind about the Light of Earendil. I kept on thinking it was Shelob speaking.
~ Denethor's firey leap of death. Bad move ~ should have kept him on the pyre.
~ Galadriel helping Frodo to his feet. She looked evil.

[Arandur]

I thought she looked the prettiest at that part . I love fire. I'm a full fledged pyro. I also hate spiders, but I think they did a sickeningly excellent job. Made my spine curl a couple times.

[Linwelos_Thranduiliel]

I liked the whole movie but what took the cake for me was the battle at pelennor fields. I love fight scenes and that just totally blew me away. It had to have been one of the parts of the movie that were priceless. Not to mention the look on the group of orcs face when aragorn and others along w/ the dead army came off the ships.

[Arandur]

The look on Theoden's face was also priceless when he saw the Witch King coming towards him on his horse in the battle of Pelennor. He was like: "My God..." ( Except that I guess they'd call him Eru instead .)

[Aredhel]

I'm just now finally getting around to this. But okay, here's what I think...
(these will probably end up being very long lists, just because.....why not *shrug*)

Best:
-opening sequence with Sméagol & Déagol in the boat(but not including the fish scene)~ it was nice to see more hobbits!! there's my reason
-''Welcome, my lords, to Isengard!!'' ;D ;D
-Hobbit drinking song in Edoras ;D
-Pippin leaving Merry! awww
-The Eldarion vision (*gasp* and it's not even a Hobbit scene!-there are more too...)
-The reforging of Narsil/making of Andúril<br>-Gandalf & Pippin arriving in Minas Tirith(wow..)
-Minas Morgul
-The lighting of the beacons!!! (Amazing scene, esp. for one that never happened in the books)
-Pippin's song/ ride to Osgiliath
-The shot of Merry riding with the Rohirrim as they are leaving, I love his expression there!!!
-''This is no place for a Hobbit!!'' and then Pippin slaying the orc! ;D Go Pip!! ::applause::
-''You will ride with me.'' ''My lady!!'' ;D
-Shelob's lair Wow my hands are in fists and I want to kill Gollum so bad in that sequence.)
-Frodo's vision of Galadriel and his expression as he stands back up. He has such a strong will! (And this is one of the only scenes in the entire trilogy that seemed to show it, and then only with the help of Galadriel! It doesn't do his character justice.)
-''Death!!!!!!!!!!!'' ::shiver::
-Gandalf trying to comfort Pippin in front of the gates of Minas Tirith, ''Death is not the end..''.
-Eówyn and the Witch King!!!! ''I am no man!!''.
-Aragorn arriving in the ships. ;D ::applause::
-Sequence of Frodo walking with his fist closed around the Ring, and the other hand trying to fight off something unseen. (A scene right from the book! Love it!)
-''I can't carry it for you, but I can carry you! Come on!''
-''For Frodo.''
-The Eagles!!!!!!! ;D
-Sequence in mt. doom with Frodo claiming the Ring and the way it was edited in with the Black Gate scenes.
-Destruction of the Ring(very climatic, but Sméagol's death is very sad I felt so bad for him)
-''Don't you let go!!'' awwww
-Everyone's reaction when they realize the Ring has been destroyed, and then when they think of Frodo.
-''Glad to be with you Samwise Gamgee, here at the end of all things.'' ;D
-Frodo waking up and being reunited with the fellowship!! ;D I absolutely love this scene and can't stop smiling through the whole thing, it's not cheesy to me at all!
-''My friends...you bow to no one.'' ;D ;D ;D
-The Grey Havens, the Grey Havens, the Grey Havens!!!!! bittersweet
-''Well, I'm back''. (I love that it ends just like the book!!!)
-lastly, any Frodo scenes not mentioned. ;D[/color]

---

Ok, now that I've pratically named the whole movie above, here are the other scenes I did not like:

-The closeup of the fish
-''The life of the eldar is leaving you'', that whole sequence.
-''Go home Sam.'' (Why PJ why? I wanted to see them go through Shelob's lair together, like in the books! clasping hands and everything ..aww so sweet! I wanted to see that![/rant])
-Aragorn's dream about Arwen.....and then the whole, Arwen's fate is tied to the Ring.....oh blaahh not needed
-Sam talking about regretting not being able to marry Rose when he's on mt.doom with Frodo..in the books she doesn't even appear until near the end, and anyways, Sam knows death has to be coming, he is going to sit there and tell Frodo what he regrets!! When he has his best friend right there and he knows they are going to die together!! I don't think so! It is just a very....odd scene that made no sense to me whatsoever!!![/endhugeannoyedrant]
-The Cirth Ungol orc who basically tells Sam, Frodo isn't dead...
-Rosie Cotton!! Go away Rose!!! ahem...
-The Eye of Sauron searchlight!! nooooo PJ noooo....now that is.....just....noooo....[/color]

Okay, and that's all! ;D I was bored so.....yeah....

[Liathwen]

I LOVED THE SONG AT THE END!

[Leggy]

I loved the whole thing. but some scenes i really did enjoy were:

-I can't carry it for you, but I can carry you! , that one made me cry!

-In Mt. Doom when gollum falls and the ring is on top looking as if it's not destroyed or anything (but hate when frodo's finger gets eaten, eww)

-That only counts as one! I thought that was so cool how Legolas brought down and Oliphaunt and then Gimli was funny.

-Elrond and Arwen scene, esp where arwen is leaving but sees her son and turns back, (just not with Arwen being tied to the ring, so stupid and not true)

-Pelennor Fields (esp, with the witch king and eowyn)


bad scenes

-when the orcs threw the heads of the people, eww

-when the orcs see faramir's helper laying there and then stab him

that's all i can think of but i haven't watched it in a while

[Nienna Greenleaf of Mirkwood]

My favorite scenes: too many to count and not enough time ;D ;D

Scenes I didn't like: well, since most of them have already been mentioned here already, I won't say them over again, but I will say that the Eye of Sauron searchlight and that Arwen's fate was tied to that of the ring (thanks, Aredhel) were at the top of the list!

~ Nienna

[TrueElvenWarrior]

loved
when arwen has a vision and talks to her father
when elrond bring aragorn the sword of the king
when aragorn becomes king
when every1 bows to the hobbits
when frodo says"how do u pick up the treats of an old life? How do u go on when in ur heart u begin to understand there is no going back? There are somethings that time cannot mend, some hurts that go too deep, that have taken hold
loved every scend other than the part when the slow frodos laugh down at the house of healing

[The Restless Shadow]

somebody other then me hates that part! ;D
lol,I'm glad I'm not alone.

[Surion]

You know, it's very interesting to know that other people think the exact same things as me... What are the odds? This movie was filled with scenes to make you cry, make you laugh, make you want to fast-forward, and make you want to watch in slow motion. What other movie, my friends, has that effect?

[Nienna Greenleaf of Mirkwood]

What movie indeed, but all three! ;D ;D ;D

~ Nienna